Free tool · No signup · Free downloads
Free menu engineering calculator
See which dishes combine strong sales with strong margins. Enter your menu prices, ingredient costs and quantities sold, or import a CSV. Get a section-by-section menu engineering report you can download for free.
Compare dishes within the same section and sales period. Use prices excluding tax and discounts, and ingredient cost per serving, in one currency.
Your menu engineering report
Total contribution before labour and overheads: 2,095.00
Stars 1
Keep quality consistent and feature this dish.
Margherita
Puzzles 1
Improve placement and description; test promotion.
Truffle pizza
Plowhorses 1
Review portions, ingredient costs or price.
Garden pizza
Dogs 1
Review its role before changing or removing it.
Four cheese
| Dish / section | Margin per dish | Popularity | Classification |
|---|---|---|---|
| MargheritaPizza | 9.00 | 46.2% | Star |
| Truffle pizzaPizza | 13.00 | 9.6% | Puzzle |
| Garden pizzaPizza | 6.00 | 38.5% | Plowhorse |
| Four cheesePizza | 6.00 | 5.8% | Dog |
High popularity means at least 70% of an equal share within the section. High margin means at least the sales-weighted average contribution per dish in that section. Sections with no sales are not classified.
Want a menu you can keep updating online? Create a free QR menu. Your tool results and downloads stay free.
How to use this tool
- Choose one sales period and enter each dish’s name, menu section, selling price, food cost per serving and quantity sold.
- Compare dishes within their sections. The tool classifies them as stars, plowhorses, puzzles or dogs using popularity and contribution margin.
- Download the CSV report or print a PDF. Use the findings to decide what to feature, reprice, improve or investigate.
Popular is not always profitable
A pizza selling for 12 with a food cost of 3 contributes 9 per sale before labour and overheads. Another selling for 11 with a food cost of 5 contributes 6. Even if both sell well, the second may be a plowhorse relative to other pizzas. Compare dishes with similar roles: mixing drinks and mains can hide useful differences.
Questions owners ask
What are stars, plowhorses, puzzles and dogs?
Stars have high popularity and high contribution margin. Plowhorses are popular with lower margins. Puzzles have higher margins but lower popularity. Dogs are below both thresholds. These are relative classifications within each menu section, not an automatic instruction to remove a dish.
How are the thresholds calculated?
A dish is popular when its share of section sales is at least 70% of an equal share. For ten dishes, the threshold is 7%. High margin means contribution per serving is at least the section’s sales-weighted average contribution. Contribution equals selling price minus ingredient cost.
What if a dish or whole section has no sales?
An unsold dish can still be classified against other dishes in a section that has sales. A section with no sales is left unclassified because popularity cannot be measured. Include a representative sales period before making decisions.
Can I import my POS sales report?
Export a CSV, then arrange its columns as name, category, price, cost, sold. Price and cost are per serving; sold is the total quantity for the chosen period. Use the downloadable example as a template. The tool supports up to 200 dishes.
Does the tool upload my sales data?
No. CSV import, calculations and CSV downloads happen in your browser. The report and printing are free without an account. Contribution margin excludes labour, rent, taxes and other overheads, so it is not net profit.
More free restaurant tools
Cost every ingredient, allow for waste, and download a recipe costing sheet.
Menu price calculator →Turn a known plate cost into a selling price, or check your food cost percentage.
RevPASH calculator →Measure revenue per available seat hour and explore better seat utilisation.